Posted by: carboncreditsusa | November 14, 2008

“National Gasoline Tax”: High OPEC Cartel Oil Prices A “Foreign Gasoline Tax” On Americans

thomasfriedman “…If you don’t think there’s a tax on oil being imposed on you by OPEC, the world’s biggest cartel, then you’re not paying attention. It just happens to be that I like my taxes to go to the U.S. Treasury to support U.S. schools and U.S. roads and U.S. buildings and U.S. commerce…” Thomas Friedman, New York Times

http://www.businessandmedia.org/printer/2008/20081113153323.aspx

“You know, people sometimes say to me, ‘How can you have a carbon tax?’” Friedman said. “If you were running for office and you offered a carbon tax, your opponent would say, ‘There goes my opponent, Mr. Friedman. He wants now a gasoline tax. He’s never seen a tax he didn’t like.”

 

     Friedman’s attitude was based on a mix of government-knows-best and protectionism. He insisted Americans already pay a tax imposed by foreign governments on energy and therefore the attitude should be to pay the tax and keep the money here.

 

     “I’ll tell you what I’d say back – I’d say, ‘Let’s get one thing straight pal – we’re both for a tax. If you don’t think there’s a tax on oil being imposed on you by OPEC, the world’s biggest cartel, then you’re not paying attention. It just happens to be that I like my taxes to go to the U.S. Treasury to support U.S. schools and U.S. roads and U.S. buildings and U.S. commerce. My opponent seems to be indifferent to that,’” Friedman said. “‘He wants his taxes to go to the Russian, the Saudi and Iranian treasury.’”

 

     Friedman missed two important points – with the so-called “tax” imposed by foreign governments, Americans get something substantive in return – energy in the form of gasoline, heating oil or any other imported fossil fuel. Friedman’s extra tax might give taxpayers the satisfaction of giving more money to a bloated bureaucratic institution – the federal government – and less product to fuel automobiles and heat homes.

 

     Also, energy prices are dictated by market forces. For example, over the last month and a half, the price of oil has fallen from nearly $100 a barrel to $56 a barrel as of Nov. 12. Fuel taxes are traditionally set per gallon rather than tied to the price, making them unsusceptible to market forces.

 

     Still Friedman insisted consumer dollars in the hands of the federal government was a better argument for politicians to make.

 

     “Well, it’s just a little tick I have, Mark,” Friedman said. “I like my money to go to build my country and if you can’t win that debate you don’t belong in politics.”

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: